Categories
Briefings

Intention and Doing

Forgive me but I am always thinking about the world too much. In my defense people have always asked me to explain things and then I usually try to cause as little annoyance as possible.

This ramble attempts to simplify such matters as intention, consciousness, morality and, as a consequence, AI. Wish me luck.

Let’s start with something we are all dependent on – Osmosis. This is where there is a barrier between two areas that is not completely sealed. The technical term is that it is a semi-permeable membrane. If the area on one side of the membrane is weaker in soluble matter than on the other side, then the soluble matter will likely seep from one side to the other until both sides are in balance. Food you eat gets from your digestive system into the rest of your body in this way, Things get from your blood stream to cells this way and at the other end your kidneys use this to send out unwanted stuff out in your urine.

So far that is mainly chemistry. Though chemistry is enormously complicated, I would say that it is not additionally burdened with the idea of Intention. While it is the kidney’s function to pass stuff across the barrier there is really no intention involved.

The body as a whole is a level of compexity way beyond that. Sadly, I am of an age that I now take tablets regularly to keep me going. That is something that I’ve tried to avoid my whole life. Each morning, as I approach my mini pharmacy, my mouth begins to salivate. That is not because I am looking forward to the flavour. It is not even because I need the saliva to start the breakdown of the tablets. It is because I know that I will need saliva to swallow the tablets without a drink. A lifetime of experience and habit mean that I don’t even have to consciously think about it. I am not reacting to a smell or other stimulus just to the start of the tablet taking activity. I have no intentional control over this. I am conscious of my body doing what it does, even though my body and me are part of the same thing.

All the systems behind this are already very complicated and they touch on some difficult ideas. I hope you can see that we can separate the activities that I’ve outlined from them being controlled by intention. That means that we can look at other levels of activity and ask more meaningful questions about intentions, such as why am I taking the tablets and what are my intentions in doing so?

On an important side-track to that, it doesn’t make sense to ask whether salivating was a moral or immoral activity but it is possible to consider asking such a question about me deciding to take the tablets.

I’m not going to add much more for now. Moving on from these small steps it is possible to start thinking about even more difficult topics such as a well fed domestic cat torturing prey that it doesn’t need for food or human hunters acting in a similar manner just for entertainment. Unlike the cat, we aspire to think about what we do and to make decisions about intention and morality.

Shifting sideways again, AI is probably more on a par with chemistry and all questions about intention and morality should be directed at the people who design, implement and use such systems. Even if you build in persuasive processes that look like consciousness, the decisions made by the AI, and probably the cat, are still your responsibility. Welcome to my world of lost sleep.